Just put Ranco RS5000 on my '96. Really like the ride. Had them on my '95 Jeep GC as well. Plus there is a Monroe rebate; when you buy 4 you get the money back for one.

 

So No real consensus.. hehe

I'm starting to lean towards the Bilstein HD from what I've read..

Anyone know of a shocks dealer who allows on-your-vehicle tests ? LOL

 

Not sure how the bilsteins are on a truck, but they were really nice for their price on my camaro. Nothing close to the Koni DA's I replaced them with, but they will be a little more on the performance side vs the other shocks you listed. Might get a little bumpy off road.