Recently my stock stereo in my 2011 Avenger is listing every station on satellite radio as a "favorite"

When I see the star icon that generally means a "favorite" is on, I press the magnifying glass button that lets you look at your favorites and every single song playing on every station is listed.

Hence, my "favorites" star icon is always on.

When I go to my Favorite song list to edit them, it only shows the songs I have selected as "Favorites."

Any help would be awesome.