1998 1500 v8 5.9L thermostat change
#21
#22
#23
Some reading for the advocates of colder stats:
http://www.importtuner.com/tech/impp...ncrease_power/
http://www.tuneruniversity.com/blog/...the-advantage/
And then we have this article, which actually shows benefits from a colder stat. I would point out however, that the control system in this test includes a Knock sensor, and the computer tries to run as much advance as it can, and this is where they think the power gains came from. Our trucks don't have one, so we don't get that benefit.
Also, the keg absorbs FAR MORE heat from the rest of the engine, which is hotter than the coolant.... than it does from the coolant running thru the crossover at the front....
So basically, the conclusion I draw from these various tests, done on real world cars is, if you have a system that can dynamically alter spark advance with a knock sensor, giving the PCM the ability to know when it's "too much", a colder stat can help you pick up some power. Without it, it's pretty much a wash, and can actually decrease engine efficiency/longevity.
That is why Hemifever recommends a 180 stat with his tunes. He dials up the timing advance, to get more power from the engine.
http://www.importtuner.com/tech/impp...ncrease_power/
http://www.tuneruniversity.com/blog/...the-advantage/
And then we have this article, which actually shows benefits from a colder stat. I would point out however, that the control system in this test includes a Knock sensor, and the computer tries to run as much advance as it can, and this is where they think the power gains came from. Our trucks don't have one, so we don't get that benefit.
Also, the keg absorbs FAR MORE heat from the rest of the engine, which is hotter than the coolant.... than it does from the coolant running thru the crossover at the front....
So basically, the conclusion I draw from these various tests, done on real world cars is, if you have a system that can dynamically alter spark advance with a knock sensor, giving the PCM the ability to know when it's "too much", a colder stat can help you pick up some power. Without it, it's pretty much a wash, and can actually decrease engine efficiency/longevity.
That is why Hemifever recommends a 180 stat with his tunes. He dials up the timing advance, to get more power from the engine.
I also agree that with a 180 degree thermostat alone you may or may not see an improvment at the wheels on a dyno alone if thats just all that you swap out, however if your engine is pinging/pre-detonating the cooler temps may prevent or reduce the effects of pre-detonation causing your engine to at least gain back the power its supposed to have from the factory, not any gains above that by itself. But I still stand by the fact it will not harm your drive-ability or throw any codes (at least on a 97 cuz thats what I have) and that the computer won't care that its there at 180 degrees, at 160 it probably would affect the pcm & float in and out of closed loop causing issues. 180 is within range of the warm up parameters of the pcm.
I personally went with the 180 degree thermostat because during the summer of 2012 the week I bought my truck and did the plenum gasket & tune up it was topping 100 degrees for Central Wisconsin for the whole week, and I was pulling a lot of stuff and using the truck a lot for grunt work so that was my motivation for installing the 180, the rest of the arguments about cooler temps = more power was just a bonus, but wasn't my main focus.
#26
#28
#30
After mudding with my brother the other day in slush melting snow & mud and seeing his chevy overheat I'm certainly glad I went with the 180 degree thermostat and NOT going above even 190!. We'd get stuck then pull eachother out and then traverse foot and a half deep ice frozen snow which was an absolute W-H-O-R-E to get through. My last trip I got almost 19 mpg on a 130 mile hwy ride with my gf, and yesterday I completely owned another 2nd gen Ram on the hwy up ramp...and after 9 months of having the 180 in I can say I suffer no efficiency issues what so ever amd it'd be fair to say I run a heck of a lot better than nearly every 2nd gen Ram in town thats near stock.