If you put it back together and it still leaks you are going to have to go buy new ones again. THe only head gaskets I know of that can be reused are multi-layered steel or copper.

That being said, it was a PITA to try and clean the old gaskets off of my truck until I bought some carbide gaskets scrapers. Since you didn't put it back together it is possible that they didn't get cleaned well.

 

Yeah, i might call around tomorrow and see how much it would cost to get the heads checked out and then go from there.