Paintable lower front valance for 2004 Dakota
#1
#2
Maybe you can sand the textured and spray it with that stuff that makes it tacky for paint. Something like Krylon Fusion for plastic.
#3
LMC sells them. Checking their website, it's 79.95 for the one without fog cutouts, and 99.95 for the one with fog cutouts, plus tax/shipping. They also have options for paint to match and textured paint to match.
http://www.lmctruck.com/icatalog/dde/full.aspx?Page=16
http://www.lmctruck.com/icatalog/dde/full.aspx?Page=16