Hey everyone,

We are currently in the Badlands.



Well here's the deal. Last night we trucked about 560 miles and half way through the truck developed a pretty bad noise in the rear. We went to the closest mechanic which is about an hour from out site. After getting the run around for a couple hours, we finally got in the shop. He thought it was a wheel bearing but ruled that out. He said the only other thing it could be is the pinion.

Now here is the question.
He said he can get a used differential from a yard in Rapid City and he could install it.
Cost around $1100
Mileage on part: 100,000
Time: from noon to 5pm

The other option is to rebuild the current differential for about the same cost if not more because of labor and said I would most likely have a noise after the rebuild.

There is also a dodge dealer in Philip which is also close but I was figuring they would cost a great deal more.

I have to call this guy at 8am mountain time to say if I want to go forward.

What other options do I have or what do you think I should do?
Is the price about right or is he inflating it because I'm from out-of-town?
Rebuild the current one or go with the used part?
Why is there so much grass out here?
Where did all these rock formations come from?

expedited answers needed please.
MAV

 

have yours rebuilt new pinion bearings, new carrier bearings, and seals my dad just had his 9.25 rebuilt for 800. as for noise if they truly rebuild it there will be no noise.