Well it turns out it was just the pulley that was bent...it saved me $15 in parts and took a lot less time than the harmonic balancer would have.

 

Glad you got it fixed.....and it was the cheaper fix. Now I wonder what bent the pulley. That's not a normal wear part!

 

Yeah its kind of weird...it is bent where the screws connect to the harmonic balancer. It almost looks like someone took a hammer to that part of it while it was off the harmonic balancer or like someone was prying on the pulley when it was attached.