Need an advice regarding winter tires
#11
#15
#17
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: South Georgia/East Florida
Posts: 24,686
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
19 Posts
You know, that's something I've often wondered about regarding going to a thinner tire for snow. Not that I'm disputing it, cause I've always heard it too, and I grew up in upstate NY where EVERYBODY used to run a "winter tire" at least those with trucks.
A snowmobile gets winter traction because of all the tread that's put in contact with snow and ice. They sell track setups for ATVs for winter use and big rig trucks boast about having much better traction in winter because of all the combined square inches of tire being put in contact with the surface.
But "they" recommend going to a thinner tire on a pickup (or SUV or passenger car for that matter). I know the theory here is to get a couple more lbs/sq. inch on the tread, but when I was ice fishing during the winters of my younger days, it seemed the guys running soccer mom treads were outperforming all the dudes with A/T and M/T treads because they had more tread making contact. They'd grip much better than anyone else short of those who run studded tires on the ice.
I always ran a thicker all-terrain tread myself and put about 200# of sand in the bed, over the rear axle and never had a problem...
A snowmobile gets winter traction because of all the tread that's put in contact with snow and ice. They sell track setups for ATVs for winter use and big rig trucks boast about having much better traction in winter because of all the combined square inches of tire being put in contact with the surface.
But "they" recommend going to a thinner tire on a pickup (or SUV or passenger car for that matter). I know the theory here is to get a couple more lbs/sq. inch on the tread, but when I was ice fishing during the winters of my younger days, it seemed the guys running soccer mom treads were outperforming all the dudes with A/T and M/T treads because they had more tread making contact. They'd grip much better than anyone else short of those who run studded tires on the ice.
I always ran a thicker all-terrain tread myself and put about 200# of sand in the bed, over the rear axle and never had a problem...
#18
I just finished reading of all threads related to winter tires so I'd like to summarize. It looks like everybody agree that having winter tire is really cool however only 1 person actually uses winter tires - Hankook I*Pike. All others are actually use different types of all seasons. Here is the list of suggested ATs for winter driving:
- Nitto Terra Grappler
- Cooper ATZ
- Firestone A/T
- Toyo Open Country A/T
Looks like all of them performs pretty well during the winter.
But I live in Ontario, in snow belt. I'm driving 100km each day on country side roads which are "plowed" but usually have packed snow. So maybe Ontarians will use winter tires anyway but they are ashame to tell about this? :-)
- Nitto Terra Grappler
- Cooper ATZ
- Firestone A/T
- Toyo Open Country A/T
Looks like all of them performs pretty well during the winter.
But I live in Ontario, in snow belt. I'm driving 100km each day on country side roads which are "plowed" but usually have packed snow. So maybe Ontarians will use winter tires anyway but they are ashame to tell about this? :-)
#20