P & N Good but R, D, 2 & 1 Cutoff Engine
hi, My 2001 3500 starts and runs fine in park and neutral but put in any other drive or reverse gear and everything shuts off instantly. There is no "sputter" just instant off.
This problem started intermittently a few days ago where I could rev it up a bit and pop it into a drive gear but now nothing. It seems to be electrical- with engine running smooth in park I take the shifter very quickly past reverse to into neutral and engine stays running smooth BUT the instant shifter passes reverse everything electric goes out for just an instant- any lights, guages etc.. It's like whatever sensor won't let you start engine in gear now won't let it run in gear either.
Thanks in advance. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.
This problem started intermittently a few days ago where I could rev it up a bit and pop it into a drive gear but now nothing. It seems to be electrical- with engine running smooth in park I take the shifter very quickly past reverse to into neutral and engine stays running smooth BUT the instant shifter passes reverse everything electric goes out for just an instant- any lights, guages etc.. It's like whatever sensor won't let you start engine in gear now won't let it run in gear either.
Thanks in advance. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.
I thought that that and my start up problems were 2 different things but maybe not. I actually didn't make it all the way home ending up in a rest area 300 miles short where I am now. I put a new ignition switch in today which didn't solve anything. Does that other hill climb stuff sound like it could have been caused by or is symptoms of a locked up torque converter? Also what is the fix for such a lock up a new TC?
Read some bad TC symptoms and I had some- shuddering and rattling sounds.
thanks.
Last edited by arty4444; Apr 27, 2018 at 07:26 PM. Reason: Addl. symptoms
Those loss of power symptoms are indicative of a weak fuel pump. A locked up TC wouldn't cause lack of power but it would cause the engine to stall in any gear other than Park or Neutral. While clogged cats would also cause a lack of power, they don't cause stalling at idle.
So yesterday I had it towed to a shop from a rest area on the highway after sitting for 4 days waiting for my one time 200 mile tow to kick in from AAA. To get it on the flatbed we pushed the van backwards 20 feet engine running in neutral. Tow driver asked me to line it up a little better not understanding it wouldn't run in gear. What the heck- I put it in gear and somehow after pushing it IT RAN ???. Even idling in nuetral I hear a rattling from the front of the tranny. Still took to shop with diagnosis later today. My main reason for this description is to ask if the shop drops the bomb "you need a new tranny" does that sound right?
Thanks.
Thanks.
Last edited by arty4444; May 2, 2018 at 11:01 AM. Reason: add info
Trending Topics
Tranny shop said everything ok with tranny but that cat. converter was clogged very badly and rattling. New cat converter going in tommorow ($300) and hopefully that will fix it. As far as instant engine cut off in any drive gear- which was the case a couple days ago but not now- I'm hoping some sensor somewhere was telling PCM not to let the van drive anywhere cause of clogged cat.
New cat. converter installed and the engine power issue is 100% fixed with tech saying there had been severe cloggage in old CC. Drove 15 miles back home from the shop making a few stops restarting the engine several times.
Now 6 hours later back to the same condition as thread title; "P and N good but R, D, 2 and 1 cutoff engine". This is after tranny shop found no problems. Engine idles smooth in P & N and "revs up" well. Thing is when engine cuts off with shift to any drive gear it is not a stall but an immediate electric shut down. Apparently I had 2 original problems with one remaining which remaining may or may not have been caused by the other (CC).
Any other ideas??
Thanks
Now 6 hours later back to the same condition as thread title; "P and N good but R, D, 2 and 1 cutoff engine". This is after tranny shop found no problems. Engine idles smooth in P & N and "revs up" well. Thing is when engine cuts off with shift to any drive gear it is not a stall but an immediate electric shut down. Apparently I had 2 original problems with one remaining which remaining may or may not have been caused by the other (CC).
Any other ideas??
Thanks
Does the truck jerk like you dumped the clutch when it dies? Or does the engine just quit running? If the latter, think I would check out the shift linkage and such, and see if it isn't pulling on a harness when you shift.









