K&N Questions
#12
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: South Georgia/East Florida
Posts: 24,686
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
19 Posts
I'm gonna play Devil's Advocate here and go against the consensus.
Not a fan of the Spectre filters myself. We did some informal testing of one on a truck (former moderators truck from here actually) that we felt was getting way too much crud in the oil and an overloaded oil filter in a relatively short period of time.
Not a real scientific test but I could set the filter on my workbench, open end down and blow PVC dust right through the filter element and have a nice pile on my bench when I lifted it up (I was building him a replacement CAI because his Spectre CAI broke from road vibrations).
We went to the local Advance and bout a K&N cone for $35 and did the same test and had NO fine powder on my workbench.
The Spectre seemed to flow just as well but obviously didn't filter worth sh*t compared to the K&N. Now granted, this was about a nine month old Spectre vs. a NIB K&N, but still the Spectre showed me enough to personally not trust it.
Run you whatever filters you want, but it was enough for me to stay clear and spend a couple extra bucks. Now on my truck, I run a K&N filter AND a pre-filter, but half my driving is on red clay dust, Georgia dirt roads...
Not a fan of the Spectre filters myself. We did some informal testing of one on a truck (former moderators truck from here actually) that we felt was getting way too much crud in the oil and an overloaded oil filter in a relatively short period of time.
Not a real scientific test but I could set the filter on my workbench, open end down and blow PVC dust right through the filter element and have a nice pile on my bench when I lifted it up (I was building him a replacement CAI because his Spectre CAI broke from road vibrations).
We went to the local Advance and bout a K&N cone for $35 and did the same test and had NO fine powder on my workbench.
The Spectre seemed to flow just as well but obviously didn't filter worth sh*t compared to the K&N. Now granted, this was about a nine month old Spectre vs. a NIB K&N, but still the Spectre showed me enough to personally not trust it.
Run you whatever filters you want, but it was enough for me to stay clear and spend a couple extra bucks. Now on my truck, I run a K&N filter AND a pre-filter, but half my driving is on red clay dust, Georgia dirt roads...
Last edited by HammerZ71; 03-14-2012 at 12:59 PM.
#13
I like my K&N FIPK-II.
The benefits that I see are greatly reduced intake air restriction (so more available power) and the washable/reusable element. If I'm going to go where it's soupy I can put a "drycharger" on and not worry about water sneaking in and making a piston go pop. Totally irrelevant: I like the sound of a Chrysler small block breathing, and with the K&N it's quite audible.
I've heard from others what Hammer's heard and seen: The Spectre filter lets too much pass, resulting in prematurely dirty oil. I've never had one, myself -- I prefer to learn from the mistakes of others when I can.
The benefits that I see are greatly reduced intake air restriction (so more available power) and the washable/reusable element. If I'm going to go where it's soupy I can put a "drycharger" on and not worry about water sneaking in and making a piston go pop. Totally irrelevant: I like the sound of a Chrysler small block breathing, and with the K&N it's quite audible.
I've heard from others what Hammer's heard and seen: The Spectre filter lets too much pass, resulting in prematurely dirty oil. I've never had one, myself -- I prefer to learn from the mistakes of others when I can.