I have some BFG AT's, and I live in Colorado were we get a lot of snow and ice. I think they are very good in the snow and dirt (dry). They are about average on ice. I haven't been in much mud with them, so I can't speak for that.

I've read that the Mud Terrains are very good in mud and snow, but really aweful on ice, like below average.

 

I love my BFG MT's I'd stay away from the AT's though. The MT's are pretty good offroad while still good on the pavement.

 

I hate anything with the BF name on it. Clone tires.

 

mudking xt's have pretty much the same tread pattern as bfg m/ts.. except A LOT cheaper i had 32x12.5 mudkings on my old gmc jimmy for 120 a peice.. nothing held that truck back with those tires

 

How about Goodyear Wranglers?

 

I just got 285/75/16 firestone destination m/t's for 450 Depending when I get them put on I can give you a review of how I like them.