Does Octane Matter?
#11
No **** that ****, every time one of these threads gets started up AGAIN, it ends up by the end of it turning into a, "I'm right, you're wrong, go **** yourself" type of deal. EVERYONE gets involved, calls each other names, etc. Before I would just post what was in an owners manual or in the FSM. On this topic I'll be a d!ck and tell everyone to go and figure it out for yourself.
#14
how bout we get back on track here guys... octane does matter do a google search and you'll find your answers. If stock always use what the manufactors recommend, and depending how much you mod it- really just with the timing of the engine and temps depends on how much more octane you need.
#16
There is a similar thread started in 2nd gen yesterday.
I'll repeat what I put in there... only three reasons you should run anything higher than what the manual states.
1. Cheaper (example: 89 octane out hear is 10% ethanol, tax breaks end up making it cheaper)
2. Hide a blown plenum gasket or similar problem (reduce ping, this is mostly for us 2nd gen guys with the 5.2L V8 or 5.9L V8, not you 4.7L V8 or 5.7L V8 3rd gen guys)
3. You have a programmer/tune that allows you to take advantage of the higher octane
The Hemi calls for 89 in the manual, put in 89. If the 4.7 calls for 87, use 87. No reason to run any higher unless you have a Hypertech, Superchips, SCT, or equivalent programmer/tune to take advantage of the higher octane rating. Factory is designed for the octane specified in the manual, going higher does absolutely nothing for you except for the previously mentioned reasons.
Biggquis, I hope the 3rd gen mods don't mind, but I am helping you out of this thread. You appear to have just popped in here to stir the pot. Lonestar may have been a little harsh, but he was on topic.
I'll repeat what I put in there... only three reasons you should run anything higher than what the manual states.
1. Cheaper (example: 89 octane out hear is 10% ethanol, tax breaks end up making it cheaper)
2. Hide a blown plenum gasket or similar problem (reduce ping, this is mostly for us 2nd gen guys with the 5.2L V8 or 5.9L V8, not you 4.7L V8 or 5.7L V8 3rd gen guys)
3. You have a programmer/tune that allows you to take advantage of the higher octane
The Hemi calls for 89 in the manual, put in 89. If the 4.7 calls for 87, use 87. No reason to run any higher unless you have a Hypertech, Superchips, SCT, or equivalent programmer/tune to take advantage of the higher octane rating. Factory is designed for the octane specified in the manual, going higher does absolutely nothing for you except for the previously mentioned reasons.
Biggquis, I hope the 3rd gen mods don't mind, but I am helping you out of this thread. You appear to have just popped in here to stir the pot. Lonestar may have been a little harsh, but he was on topic.
Last edited by jasonw; 08-19-2010 at 02:41 AM.
#17
#18
I would agree with Marx, however it's NEVER a BAD IDEA to run a higher octane gas than the engine calls for. IT WILL NEVER DO ANYTHING NEGATIVE to your engine, but it may not do any better than the octane the engine is tuned for either.
Because the profit margin is higher in higher octane fuels, many gas/oil companies use better (more expensive) additive packages with the premium fuels. So over the long haul, engine life could theoretically be extended when using these fuels.
IF any engines documentation states: XX octane is ok, but XX octane is recommended. USE THE HIGHER OF THE TWO! UNLESS the engine has knock sensors built into it, like the 4.7 HO. The standard 4.7 & HEMI does NOT...
Because the profit margin is higher in higher octane fuels, many gas/oil companies use better (more expensive) additive packages with the premium fuels. So over the long haul, engine life could theoretically be extended when using these fuels.
IF any engines documentation states: XX octane is ok, but XX octane is recommended. USE THE HIGHER OF THE TWO! UNLESS the engine has knock sensors built into it, like the 4.7 HO. The standard 4.7 & HEMI does NOT...
#19
If you ever get into advance tuning and actually WATCH the PID you record and how they react with lower octanes versus higher, you will visually see the difference. If you can see the different and understand the mechanics of an engine then you can understand why higher octane can be better.
I did not learn all of this until recently even though I have built several engines in the past. But the tuning aspect is what I am learning and can now understand.
I did not learn all of this until recently even though I have built several engines in the past. But the tuning aspect is what I am learning and can now understand.