Hemi vs Cummins
#11
The previous owner of my Hemi used to tow around 8000-9000 pounds with it, without much trouble. But, he was towing quite a bit and needed a bigger truck so he bought a Ford F-550 diesel with a dump bed 4WD, and dualies in the back. He now tows his 8000 pound trailer along with 4 pallets of Sod, or 3-4 yards of dirt in the dump bed. It is perfect for his side work, but he's doing landscaping/light excavating part-time so he really puts the truck to use.
I don't know what kind of mileage he got when he was towing with my Hemi, but he was happy with it's ability to tow even with the 3.55 gears.
I don't know what kind of mileage he got when he was towing with my Hemi, but he was happy with it's ability to tow even with the 3.55 gears.
#13
#15
#16
#17
The longer the truck, the harder it is to maneuver in tight spaces. I'm afraid that I don't understand the 'leverage' thing. What do you mean?
The trailer he uses has electric brakes. I still have the controller. The truck has big disk brakes on all 4 wheels. Do they actually put different brakes on the 4-door and longbed trucks?
The trailer he uses has electric brakes. I still have the controller. The truck has big disk brakes on all 4 wheels. Do they actually put different brakes on the 4-door and longbed trucks?
#19
I was questioning the concern over braking made by another poster - regardless of the length of the truck, a properly loaded trailer with its own brakes should not present a problem for a 5000 pound truck. I could see an issue if the trailer were loaded way too far back but my friend has a pretty good idea of what he's doing.
#20
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: South Georgia/East Florida
Posts: 24,686
Likes: 0
Received 20 Likes
on
19 Posts
After actually having a diesel, there's not that much different in price for maintenance compared to gas. Yea the oil changes are 3 gallons but the oil you use is just the regular kind, nothing synthetic. The price of fuel is easily made up in the MPG. You can do all the math you want that suggests otherwise but in the real world diesel is cheaper to operate. Then theres the price of the truck itself but in your case you are buying used and a couple years older which is going to be less than a new hemi if you were to buy one. Im just saying from experience, I would go diesel way before gas even if its not a dodge. Not to mention putting a programmer on it and smoking any hemi out there (majority of them) then driving home getting 20mpg.
I actually went to buy a new '04 CTD 4x4 when I ended up with my Hemi, as with all the rebates and discounts my Hemi which stickered for only $9k less, actually came out to $17k less than the diesel. Since I don't tourney bass fish anymore and have a daily driver, I only put about 8k miles a year on my truck, so for that kinda money difference, I just couldn't justify the CTD.
But I've had both and to a point I agree with you. Fuel economy is pretty much a wash, diesel costs more, but you'll enjoy better fuel economy. Tune-ups can cost 3x more, but you only have to do them a third of the time compared to a gasser, so that's a wash.
What gets you with a diesel is the cost if something breaks! My local dealer charges more than double just for the diagnostic check (I have no clue why, since they hook up the same damn machine!), and repairs are through the roof. I had an injector go in my Furd diesel and the stealership wanted $900 (yes that's NINE-HUNDRED DOLLARS!) to replace it. Luckily, I had/have a buddy who is a certified big rig mechanic who changed it out with me. If I don't know how to do something, I'd prefer to do it, but love it when I have a mentor over my shoulder, LOL.
Repairs are just STUPID high on a diesel. Some people just want one and can afford it and some people NEED a diesel, I just couldn't justify it...